Tuesday, July 9, 2013

Alfred Schonlank v Muthunayna Chetti

Alfred Schonlank v Muthunayna Chetti


Summary of Facts: The defendant left an offer to sell a quantity of indigo at the plaintiff's office allowing him eight days time to give his acceptance. The defendant then revoked his offer on the fourth day and plaintiff accepted it on the fifth day.  The plaintiff files the suit for the specific performance of the contract.

Issues: Whether an offer with an option to accept within a fixed period could be withdrawn before the expiry of that period?

Holding: An offeror can withdraw an offer with an option to accept within a fixed period before the expiry of that period if the offeree has not accepted the offer before it is withdrawn.

Rationale: The court observed that the acceptance is useless as both on principle and on authority it is clear that there is no consideration for the promise to keep the offer open for a time once it is withdrawn.

3 comments:

  1. Sirs and Madams, this is an excellent resource for us. Con you please give us the case brief of the case Haji Mohammad Haji Jiva v E. Spinner

    ReplyDelete
  2. Nice explain only important thing is cover

    ReplyDelete

Powered by Blogger.

© Indian Case Briefs, AllRightsReserved.

Designed by ScreenWritersArena